“IT TASTES JUST LIKE MOM’S” — GWYNETH PALTROW’S SIMPLE DISH LEFT SAVANNAH GUTHRIE IN TEARS AND THE ENTIRE ROOM SILENT

Gwyneth Paltrow baffles Savannah Guthrie with bizarre diet hack

Got arugula?

Gwyneth Paltrow revealed on the “Today” show Wednesday that she substitutes milk with the leafy greens in her recipes — a comment that visibly baffled Savannah Guthrie.

“If you want to avoid dairy, one trick that I do is I dice up arugula and I put it in,” the Goop creator, 53, explained while making turkey meatballs for a cooking segment.

Gwyneth Paltrow mixing ingredients in a bowl on "Today 2 Food" while a man watches and Savannah Guthrie smiles.
Gwyneth Paltrow baffled Savannah Guthrie with a cooking hack on Wednesday.TODAY
Gwyneth Paltrow on Today Food.
The Goop creator told the “Today” show host she substitutes milk with arugula while cooking.TODAY
“Really?” Guthrie, 54, asked. “That’s weird.” 

Acknowledging that the swap did “sound weird,” Paltrow claimed, “It kind of adds a nice texture to it, and it’s delicious.”

Guthrie gave the move the “OK” as the actress continued to cook.

Gwyneth Paltrow mixing turkey meat for meatballs on the Today Show.
“Really?” Guthrie asked during the cooking segment.TODAY
Gwyneth Paltrow demonstrates a turkey mixture recipe on Today Food with two co-hosts.
The journalist quipped, “That’s weird.”TODAY
Social media users had a heyday with the clip, with one quipping, “When I don’t have milk for my pancake mix, I just add lawn clippings.” 

Another joked, “If my grandmother had wheels, she would be a bike!”

Others demanded Paltrow go “straight to jail,” while some sarcastically recommended “dirt” or “wood chips” for “texture.”

Gwyneth Paltrow speaking into a microphone.
The actress (pictured above on May 5), however, insisted, “It kind of adds a nice texture to it, and it’s delicious.”goop/YouTube
Gwyneth Paltrow holding a roasting pan with two roasted chickens in a kitchen.
The Oscar winner (pictured above in April 2025) has repeatedly made headlines for her eating habits over the years.gwynethpaltrow/Instagram

One fan, however, came to the Oscar winner’s defense in the comments section.

“It sounds odd but I think it’s out of context,” the Instagram user wrote. “Instead of adding grated parmigiano, you can absolutely add diced arugula. This will lighten the texture and add flavor and moisture.”

Paltrow has made headlines for her food takes in the past, with Meghan McCain accusing the “Marty Supreme” star of promoting a “starvation diet” in 2023.

The callout, notably, came after Paltrow divulged on “The Art of Being Well” podcast that she ate bone broth for lunch, did intermittent fasts and used IV drips.

Gwyneth Paltrow takes a mirror selfie wearing a pink strapless top, black leggings, and black heels.
Paltrow (pictured above in December 2024) made waves for confessing she eats bone broth for lunch in 2023.gwynethpaltrow/Instagram
Gwyneth Paltrow takes a selfie while sitting on a wooden floor in a tan long-sleeved shirt and white shorts.
Two years later, the Emmy winner (pictured in October 2021) admitted to having been “strict” with her diet.gwynethpaltrow/Instagram

The Golden Globe winner subsequently defended herself via Instagram Stories, insisting, “I eat full meals. I also have days where I eat whatever I want, French fries or whatever. My baseline has been to try to eat healthy.”

Last year, Paltrow admitted to having been “a little strict” with her eating in the past as she gushed over quitting the Paleo diet.

“I’m getting back into eating sourdough bread, cheese. … A little pasta,” she shared with “Goop Podcast” listeners in April 2025. “There I said it.”